A Tale of Two Teachers: Why You Shouldn't Try to Be the Favorite

A Tale of Two Teachers: Why You Shouldn't Try to Be the Favorite

 tale of two teachers - favorite teacher cover

Adam Hatch Bored Teachers

This article was written by Adam Hatch - UC Berkeley graduate, son of a teacher, brother of a teacher, and a teacher himself. Adam started a unique English school in Taipei, Taiwan, where kids learn to research and write articles in English. The articles are published on the first ever English newspaper written by kids in Taiwan, called the Taipei Teen Tribune.
*This article was written by a guest author. It has not been vetted or endorsed by Bored Teachers' editorial staff.*


Here is a tale of two teachers: the favorite teacher and the best teacher.

In rare instances they can be the same, but not often. Many students confuse their favorite with the best, but that’s a common misconception. Hear me out: as a teacher, you shouldn’t try to be the favorite.

My favorite teacher was not the best teacher. She was a wonderful person - empathetic, helpful, patient, and she made class a comfortable and fun place to be. However, in her pursuit of having an accommodating classroom and a good relationship with all of her students, she also sacrificed authority and a certain degree of respect.

On the other hand, my best teacher wasn’t my favorite. I didn’t always like her class and sometimes I found the work and her teaching downright boring. And while she was perfectly nice, especially one-on-one, she held firm authority in her classroom and simply didn’t get as close to her students as some other teachers did.


But do you know what she did do? She made us work, and work hard. I realized after I graduated that I learned more in her class than any other course I had taken up to that point. And part of the reason was because she resisted trying to be everyone’s favorite and strove instead to be the best.

Why does it have to be this way? The problem is, favorite teachers, at least most of the time, try to be too much of a “friend” to their students, and students are easily tempted into taking advantage of this relationship. Students don’t mean to, but when they are confident a teacher is going to be “cool” with them being late to class, for example, eventually they try to cash in on the supposed friendship.

Even if the favorite teacher is firm and still disciplines the student, both the teacher and the student find themselves in a situation where they rather resent each other. The student feels like a “friend” has been “uncool” and the teacher feels their patience and kindness have been taken advantage of. And even worse, should the favorite teacher actually let poor behavior slide, they also begin to lose authority and consistency, thus planting the seeds for future difficulties.

The favorite teacher is often spoken highly of, especially by students. However, if you listen to what people actually say, praise for this teacher is rarely academic in nature. It’s usually about how nice they are or how cool their class is, never about how much a student has improved or how something they’d taught had deep effect. Furthermore, favorite teachers are often best with students who are going to be fine regardless of who their teacher is - this kind of instructor rarely is able accomplish the herculean task of getting unengaged students to focus and improve.


So how do you avoid falling into this trap, but still foster meaningful relationships with students? Teachers need to remember: you aren’t there to be your students’ friend. The point isn’t to be everyone’s buddy, the point is to motivate and galvanize. Your job is to be a role model and to engage your pupils’ intellects. Education is a highly social dynamic, and one that demands a tremendous amount of respect from students and authoritative competence from teachers. Anything less is the first step on a slippery slope to dysfunction.

Good feelings and relationships with students are important, but the best teacher instills competence and skill and realizes education is not about what the teacher can take away from his class, but rather about equipping students with the tools they need to succeed in life. And this usually means forgetting about being popular and focusing the fundamentals of your craft.

In other words, don’t worry about being the favorite - try to be the most respected. Be the teacher that parents want their students to have because they’ve heard how much you can get students to accomplish. Simply put, strive to be the best.


bored teachers blog

Other Posts You'll Also Love:

Mom's Rant About Giving Teachers More Credit Will Make Your DayMom's Rant About Giving Teachers More Credit Will Make Your Day

This Floor Stops People From Running in Halls and Schools Need it So BadThis Floor Stops People From Running in Halls and Schools Need it So Bad

6 Tips to Help You Maintain Your Sanity At Parent-Teacher Conferences6 Tips to Help You Maintain Your Sanity At Parent-Teacher Conferences


  • Janet

    While I agree with most of this article, my teaching partner and I both ran very disciplined classrooms where the students learned and exceeded expectations; the students were also nurtured as individuals but were clear on the lines of teacher/student. Maybe this is easier to maintain in an elementary classroom and lines blur more as students grow up. I do know that many of my second grade students are now adults well into their 30’s and have made the effort to come back and let me know I was their favorite teacher and they wished their children could have experienced my classroom.

  • Brianna Call

    I do agree with most of the points made in the article. Although, I do come from teaching K-2 so my view of being a friend versus “the best” coincide. I am one of the first foundational years for these kiddos and I set the stage as to whether they have a relatively good experience in school or hate it. Yes, this can be changed by amazing teachers down the road. All I’m saying is yes there are teachers who play JUST the friend and their management suffers as does their academic success (I was this my first year teaching and I suffered because of it, but also learned from it). Coming from the little part of education I see a tightly woven line where there is a friendliness that is present in my teaching, but an expectation still that I am the teacher and they are the students and with that comes a mutual respect.

    Great article, got me thinking. :)

  • Jackie M Beyer

    Thanks. Ive been struggling with this so much and this is my 6th year in my district. I don’t know that I care as much as that my students like me is I want them to enjoy learning and coming to school. But they definitely always end up taking advantage of my kindness. I like the way you say strive to be the best. One thing I’ve learned every student and every parent isn’t gonna like you know matter what.

  • Laura

    I honestly don’t agree with this 100%. I agree that I’m not there to be my kids’ friend, I have my own friends, and I still make executive decisions that not everyone is thrilled with. I do, however, have close relationships with my students and that allows me to discipline without yelling and keep control of my classroom. Especially with some of my more difficult students, the connection we have allows me to both help and correct them because they know I love them and am there for them no matter what.

  • Natalia

    I’m newly qualified teacher and I really needed to read that, cause i tend to make that mistake – try to be friendly with students and as a result they try to take advantage of it… I’ll do my best to change it. But what I wanted to say is that i remember one teacher, I was 13 or 14 when she was teaching me. During lessons – a monster! She was pushing us to the limits, everyone was a champion in physics after her class. She was making quizes almost during every class (to check if we repeated material at home), she was giving tones of homework. And let’s face it – physics is not a favourite subject of 14 years old children. I was very good student, so i didn’t feel so bad after her classes, but some of my collegues were finishing up with tears in eyes. Things were changing completly when it was anything apart from lessons. She was the first one to make fitness battle trachers vs children (who can make it better and longer), she didn’t have problem with wearing any embarassing costume for assembly, she was the most funny and energetic during school trips. She organized once a month scary stories night and then sleepover at school. Whenever weather was good, she was doing campfires for students and constantly telling jokes… She was (and probably still is) the best and the favourite teacher. Of course, there were students that hated her, but there was noone who doesn’t remember anything from her classes.

Leave a comment

Please note, comments must be approved before they are published

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

You may also like View all